April 15, 2019, 3:41 pm
The Court in Florida’s Fifth District Court of appeals affirmed the conviction but remanded the sentence (before a different judge) of a man who was sentenced to 100 years for CP.
The opinion in Berben v. State, which came out this past Friday, found that the Court’s decision violated the Defendant’s Eighth Amendment constitutional due process rights. Berben was found guilty of twenty counts of knowingly possessing, controlling, or intentionally viewing images depicting child pornography. The trial court then imposed twenty consecutive five-year sentences for a total of 100 years.
“When imposing the sentence, the trial court made specific and unsubstantiated comments, concluding that Berben had actually distributed the pornographic images and further equating such conduct to actual, physical or sexual abuse of a minor… Further, the trial court saw “little difference in the culpability between those who actually sexually abuse and exploit children and those who encourage and promote conduct by downloading and sharing videos of such,” neither of which Berben was charged with.” As one of the concurring opinions mentioned, “Make no mistake, those who possess child pornography face lengthy prison sentences. However, they are not generally sentenced to life in prison.”
The other interesting part of this order was that the Judges took it upon themselves to make the correct legal argument on behalf of the Defendant. They note that the issue on which they were basing their decision on was not preserved or argued in the Appeal. However, they pointed out that an appellate court can address errors on it’s own volition if it is determined to be fundamental and is apparent on the face of the record.
The post Appeals Court rules man sentenced to 100 years for CP should be resentenced. appeared first on Florida Action Committee.
Go to Source
Author: Florida Action Committee
The opinions expressed within posts and comments are solely those of each author, and are not necessarily those of Women Against Registry.
Women Against Registry Family Foundation.
We will receive .5% of your total purchase as a donation from amazon.
If you want to shop at amazon, please shop at
smile.amazon.com/ch/47-4076038
Our organizations, Women Against Registry and WAR Family Foundation, do not support or condone illegal sexual activity based on state and federal laws, to include child or adult sex trafficking. We are not and have never been affiliated with any organizations that promote, support or condone sex between adults and minors.
